ARISTOTLE'S COMMENTS ON COMEDY

Posted by JOTTINGS ON LITERATURE | Sunday, October 04, 2009 | , , | 0 comments »

Aristotle says that the origin of comedy is obscure. Nothing is known about the person or persons who introduced the masques and the various characters either. However, the compositions of the plots originated in Sicily, says Aristotle. Comedy emerged out of Satire which in turn is believed to have originated from the phallic songs. Phallic songs are songs sung during the worship of Dionysus. The Orphic Mysteries tell us a lot about Dionysus. Dionysus was the god of wine and of the sense of liberation from human bondage and of access to divinity that intoxication bestows. Comedy evolved out of Satire in course of time. The major difference between a satire and a comedy is that while the former deals with the personal the latter deals with the general. Satire is a scathing personal attack. Comedy portrays man in his worst aspects. It does not portray man as cruel or wicked. It points to the defective and the ugly aspects of man. The comical actions are not destructive or harmful. Though it does make us laugh our hearts out it does not make fun of or hurt anyone personally. It is that they are ludicrous by nature. Aristotle does not see any malice in the pleasure derived from a comedy as Plato does. According to Plato defects in a person should arouse the feeling of sympathy not laughter in the audience. However, Aristotle points to the fact that the defects that make the audience laugh is not personal but general. What evokes laughter is the follies and weakness of a ‘type’. And hence it does not hurt anyone. Aristophanes’ ‘Wasps’, ‘Clouds’, ‘Frogs’ are the most famous Greek comedies. The function of a comedy is correction of society. However, the impact of a comedy may not last as long as that of a tragedy.

ARISTOTLE'S COMMENTS ON EPIC

Posted by JOTTINGS ON LITERATURE | Wednesday, September 23, 2009 | , , , , | 0 comments »

Epic is older than tragedy. Epic evolved out of hymns to Gods and songs sung in praise of heroes. It has many things in common with tragedy. Tragedy came out of epic. Aristotle says that an epic is an imitation of action that is serious, whole and complete. Aristotle has said that one who knows tragedy also knows epic. Unlike tragedy an epic is meant to be read. An epic has plot, character, thought and diction. The plot may be simple or complex, just as the plot of a tragedy. The objective of an epic also is to produce catharsis in the readers by arousing the feelings of pity and fear in their minds. Though Aristotle does not say so explicitly, the plot is the most important constituent of an epic. However, an epic involves narration not dramatic action. It must have a beginning, a middle part, and an end. However, the parts are not to be organized as in the case of historical writings. In the case of historical writings the focus is not on a single action but a particular period of time. The historian refers to all the important persons and events in the period .The relations between the persons and events or between the persons may not be very clear. In an epic the poet focuses his attention on a particular action. According to Aristotle Homer is the best epic poet as he did not include everything that happened during the Trojan War. An epic can be long or short as there is no limit to narration. The poet has the freedom to move from place to place as he likes.
The poet may stay back and let the characters to speak. As the poet does not have to convince the audience in theatre as in the case of tragedy, he can indulge in his imagination and narrate things as he thinks. Aristotle also says that the heroic hexameter is the appropriate meter for the epic as it has the greatest stability. It helps the poet to employ various metaphors in his narration. The trochaic and iambic tetra meter is appropriate for dancing. Only the literate can read and enjoy epics. Anyone even if the person is illiterate, can watch and enjoy a tragedy. However, those who can read will be able to watch a tragedy and enjoy it. Aristotle believes that a tragedy can produce more pleasure than an epic can. And hence tragedy is the best form of poetry.

ARISTOTLE'S CONCEPT OF A TRAGIC HERO

Posted by JOTTINGS ON LITERATURE | Saturday, September 05, 2009 | , , | 0 comments »


In his, book ‘Poetics’, Aristotle has enumerated the characteristics of a tragic hero. To arouse the feelings of pity and fear in the spectators, the tragic hero should not be a perfect man or a bad man. The picture of a perfect man falling from grace will not arouse the feelings of pity and fear in the spectators. It would just shock them. They would think if a perfect man suffers and dies like that they with their defects could never hope for a good life. They would not benefit from that state of mind in any way. The fortune of a bad man turning from bad to good also is unacceptable. The tragic incidents in the life of a bad person will not arouse the feelings of pity and fear in the spectators. Besides, a bad person does not deserve a good fortune. The fall of a wicked and cruel person will lead to a sense of satisfaction and a sigh of relief in the spectators. In between these two extremes there is a kind of man who is neither remarkably good nor a worthless person. He is “a man who enjoys property and high reputation like Oedipus”. The fall of such a person, says Aristotle, due not to his vice or an intervention from outside, but to an error of judgment or a fatal flaw in the person, will lead to the arousal of the feelings of pity and fear in the spectators. This happens because the misfortune is out of proportion to his error in judgment. The suggestion that a great misfortune can befall even a good man due to an error in his judgment will arouse the feeling of fear. And the essential goodness makes the spectators to identify themselves with the hero and take pity for him.